Horse Sense (and Sensibility)

About Stephanie

Stephanie L. Church, Editor-in-Chief of The Horse, received a B.A. in Journalism and Equestrian Studies from Averett College in Danville, Va., and has worked in five positions at the magazine since 1999. Her equine background is in eventing, and she enjoys photography, cooking, cycling, swimming, and traveling in her free time.

My eyelids have finally returned to normal after two days of crying-induced puffiness, so it's time to weigh in on War Horse, the source of my emotional display in a Lexington cinema on Monday.

The highly anticipated film whose trailer even had me in tears when I saw it for the first time back in August was one I will return to see in the theater and will own on DVD.

Courage Under Fire

This sketch by War Horse equine makeup artistic director Ali Bannister appeared briefly in the film, along with several of her other sketches. Freelance correspondent Christa Lesté-Lasserre met Bannister at a press event late last year.

I've avoided reading other blogs on the subject so I wouldn't be tempted to parrot or build on their messages. What's my specific angle? Like many of the War Horse watchers, I've spent a lifetime around horses. I love a good film, especially a Spielberg one. My sister studied film set design and in watching movies with her, I've picked up on some of the nuances for which she watches. Like many I also have a penchant for war stories, after hearing my grandmother describe stories from the other World War (I visited the museum to that war in Caen, France, in 2000). What might make my angle a little unique is that in my career I've focused primarily on horse health, and as an editor I'm generally fastidious about details and accuracy. This is sometimes to the detriment of my consumption of a movie. I've also seen some remote areas of France while competing in an orienteering competition on horseback (mind you, I wasn't good at this sport, but I did finish a nine-hour solo ride with a map, a compass, and an Arabian named "Uloa"). From this perspective, here are some things that impacted me the most about this movie. Warning: There are spoilers ahead, if you haven't yet seen the film.

  • A truly idyllic setting that embraces the viewer almost immediately, reminding them of past rides on memorable mounts. If you've traveled in Europe--especially if you've ridden in Europe--and enjoyed your visit, you might begin having pangs of homesickness within minutes. I guess this is true for any idyllic scene (California? Virginia?) where the warm afternoon light hits the fences, trees, and grass in such a way that you'd like to bottle it for safe keeping. Before I remembered from reading our recent articles (Horses Get Star Treatment on War Horse Set, Movie Magic, Makeup, and Tricks shape War Horse) that most of the film locations were in England--nope, haven't gone riding there--I had convinced myself that I'd seen that bend in the road, that tree, that field. The ability for the viewer to relate to the setting was uncanny.
  • A swift but subtle transport from reality to story. Joey's first few nickers and whinnies at Albert's family's farm came from a horse whose nostrils weren't moving (that I remember). Something about that moment made me say, “Okay, Steph, this is a movie. Let it go.” At that point details in the rest of the film--from the sequences showing training and behavior to comical tricks--did not distract me in the least, aside from one moment in the barbed-wired-no-man's-land scene where I pulled myself out of the story long enough to remember this was not a live horse suffering amidst a tangle of rusted wire. (And thank God it wasn't.) Bobby Lovgren and the other trainers did an incredible job of training the multiple Joeys and the background horses, and of replicating the body condition scores of animals that had been at war. It had to have been an epic task, and I applaud their hard work.
  • The almost-charmed existence of Joey, a horse who always had an advocate Whether it was Albert, Captain Nicholls, Emilie, or a host of others, this horse always had caretakers looking out for him the best way they could or knew how. They may have been uneducated in their efforts at times, but Joey was patient and gracious. Alternately, they may have been well-educated in husbandry and wanted to do more to help Joey, but did not have the means, so they did what they could. In return Joey cared for them (although he probably would've done it anyway) and for his equine friend--in a sacrificial, unconditional way that could open yet another angle of discussion, but I'll leave that to a friend who will be writing about spiritual themes throughout War Horse on another blog. I also want to put a plug in for the veterinarian who comes through and continues Joey's treatment after he and Albert reunite; having an advocate in that veterinarian also impacted me as well, seeming that I love me some compassionate vets!
  • The filmmakers don't rely on gruesome effects to represent loss. As I recall the moment where Captain Nicholls sees his plight, and the immediately following scene where Joey continues galloping forward toward the enemy, riderless, my waterworks begin again. So many filmmakers rely on assaulting viewers' senses to draw them into the story. My awareness of the sheer enormity of what World War I soldiers were faced with in their trenches was heightened, but I wasn't so pummeled with gore that I had to look away or that I became desensitized. There was an ebb and flow to the awareness of the pain, misery, fear, and courage that happened in those battlefields.
  • The bond between a person and his/her horse is profound. Where my heart strings were pulled especially taut was the portrayal of the strength of a bond between horse and human. Like many of our readers, I've had a bond with a particular remarkable horse--a bond that to this day brings tears to my eyes when I recall it. It's a oneness that to others who haven't experienced it might sound a wee bit too mystical or cliché. For nonhorsepeople, maybe it is best likened to a bond between them and faithful friends of another species--dog, cat, whatever. But Spielberg and his team captured this bond between boy and horse probably more closely than I've seen in any other movie featuring an animal as its protagonist over the years.

My hope is that this movie will reach people who have never been around horses, and they might seek to experience the bond that is between rider and horse--taking a riding lesson, perhaps, or visiting a friend who owns horses and learning how to groom or help with the stalls. Also I hope that they'll linger on the themes of sacrifice, steadfastness, and loyalty, something that we don't necessarily see all too often in theaters, or even in our day-to-day.

Your Turn: If you've seen the movie, what did you think? What aspects impacted you the most?

Filed under:

Comments

My husband and I saw the movie on New Years Day! I do NOT like war movies but the horse won over my objections. The movie was beautiful from human and animal relationships and scenery, the war story lines were not so graphic for most (I did cover my eyes a couple of times) but the reality of war and the scars it leaves behind on humans, animals an our surroundings cannot be forgotten. I hope everyone takes positive messages from the movie.

MOST importantly I came home and with hugs an bran mash and quiet time promised to my 3 horses that they will always have a home and love and care with me.



Ronda 05 Jan 2012 3:06 PM

That's so sweet, Ronda! Thanks for sharing. Sounds like you have 3 very lucky horses.



Stephanie 05 Jan 2012 3:17 PM

I thought the movie was very well done.  I'm actually glad it had no big name actors in it except for the horses themselves.  

I'm also biased because pencil sketches of my horse (created by my artist friend Ali Bannister) were modified and used in the movie.  Ali talks about the artwork in the movie on her website.  I'm just proud that my OTTB had a role - small as it is - in the movie.  www.warhorseart.com



Wendy 05 Jan 2012 3:43 PM

I have not seen the movie yet, but I cried like a baby when I watched the trailer. I guess I will need to take  a box of tissue with me when I  do go see the movie....can't wait to see it. I also hope this movie will strengthen the equine community as well and get people interested in horses again.

I tried to find out more about the horses in the movie-but couldn't find any info on them, other than they were very pampered.



dana 05 Jan 2012 3:54 PM

I really enjoyed this movie.  It is heart wrenching when horses were simply taken from their owners and forced into the war role - I couldn't believe the audacity with which it was done.  I am also glad the horse caught in the barb wire was not real. Just watching Joey race terrified through nomansland collecting the barb wire horrified me.  Seeing the reunion of the boy, Joey, and the parents was such a good ending. I get sick of bad outcomes and question marks.  It is nice to have a good ending, we need them.  I am glad I saw this movie.



Thea 05 Jan 2012 3:57 PM

Very cool, Wendy! Thanks for sharing. I think one our our writers got to know Ali during a press event in Europe. She mentioned really liking her!



Stephanie 05 Jan 2012 4:01 PM

Dana, I didn't take tissues and I had two mascara-covered sleeves. So good for you for being prepared! Thea, I'm glad you saw it as well.



Stephanie 05 Jan 2012 4:03 PM

I love that "War Horse" is a story about a boy and his horse. With so many women and girls involved with horses, I think it's really great to see examples of boys and men forming bonds with horses! It's not a narrative we see all that often anymore in the media (not like the days of John Wayne and Roy Rogers). Although, the recent films "Buck" and "Wild Horse, Wild Ride" do have some great examples, as well. Horses are cool for boys too! :)



Michelle 05 Jan 2012 4:24 PM

Thanks, Michelle! I agree wholeheartedly.

[Speaking of men ... I was kind of disappointed there wasn't a love story that stemmed from either Albert meeting the girl from the car or a grown-up Emilie (I'd pictured Emilie with the regimental ribbon meeting Albert later, years after the war! But I guess there's only so much you can fit into a film!]



Stephanie 05 Jan 2012 5:06 PM

Wonderful movie, the running through barbwire really got to me and the men in the trench, Loved the doctor scene, and the fact that Joey got home in one piece.

also thought that the plowing scene where the run away was funny.



Janette 05 Jan 2012 8:26 PM

War Horse has the feel of another story, Black Beauty, in that it shows us some of the history of the horse living/working, serving us/supporting us, in peace/at war, mostly as a disposible commodity yesterday, today and in most of the world.  War Horse reminds us of the intelligence, nobility, loyalty and strength inherent in each horse,and Joe reinforces the knowledge that an emotional bond can be formed which lasts a lifetime.



Paddi 05 Jan 2012 10:22 PM

Just returned from the movie and will go again and take the hubby!  I have pony trekked in England, Ireland and France so the scenery made me nostalgic immediately.  I had attended a local meeting regarding the new horse slaughter bill and several influential people in the industry as well as film makers were there to advise us that horses were not injured and about the mechanical horse with the wire so that prompted me to view the movie.  I thought it was magical.  Truly touches the soul.  Perhaps our politicians should have to see it!



Jan 05 Jan 2012 10:48 PM

You've convinced me to go see the movie.  After bawling through the trailer, I decided I couldn't handle the movie but now...perhaps I can.  Thanks to your magazine for the articles about the real horses in the film.



Sandra 05 Jan 2012 11:18 PM

There's been no mention of the PLAY that resulted in the movie, and came as a result of the BOOK. If you haven't seen the clips on YouTube, do so! I knew I had to read the book before I dared watch the movie, but once i saw the clips, I knew I MUST see the play, too. The horses are lifesized and rideable puppets, but you realize very quickly that you see only the horses themselves moving. They are nothing short of AMAZING. fyi - I'm told the barbed wire in the movie is rubberized styrofoam;  Spielburg promised no horse would even be scratched! Watch his interviews, too.



Virginia 06 Jan 2012 2:10 AM

I know it's probably just me, but I couldn't help noticing every time a different horse portrayed Joey from scene to scene.  One in particular had a decidedly "Roman nose."  :-) That aside, I have to say I really liked the movie.  Back in the WWI era, horses were still mostly observed as beasts of burden or mode of transportation rather than pets.  It's nice to have a story that has Joey going from good hands to good hands, with his well-being (mostly) looked after simply for being the noble creature he is, not for what task he can perform.  



PAIGE 06 Jan 2012 7:35 AM

Janette, Christa (our international correspondent who attended a War Horse press event) assures me the barbed wire was a harmless material, as Virginia concurs. Also, Virginia, our digital editor/producer, Michelle Anderson, will be seeing the play on Broadway this month!!

Sandra, do go. You'll enjoy it. (If you're Sandra-My-Mom, make sure you take Dad.)

Paige, I was with you on the recognizing the different horses. In some shots as an adult horse Joey was heavier-boned than others, and of course there was the Roman-nosed factor. I was able to let it go after a few scenes, though!



Stephanie 06 Jan 2012 9:14 AM

The movie portrayed the bond between human and horse very well.  Steven S. forgot a few things, however, like:  a horse's back is WET when you take the saddle and pad off; their nostrils move when they nicker, etc. We forget how horses were used during that period of the century.  We are very lucky to have them now, as opposed to then.  



Carol 06 Jan 2012 6:19 PM

I have to admit, I sobbed during the barbed wire scene.  I don't usually do such things at movies, but I kept seeing my own horse in that terrible situation in my mind.  Having read the book, I knew I HAD to see the movie and I was pleased that the movie actually improved a bit on some of the book, especially concerning the father's motives for his behavior.   I'd love to see the play, but it probably won't come near Podunk, VA....;-)...Hurray for Spielburg for turning a 'child's' book into a spectacular movie.



DIANE 07 Jan 2012 6:45 PM

Stephanie, I enjoyed your review—it gave me more to think about with the film. I, too, was in tears most of the way through it. I think you captured that emotional aspect so well when you mentioned about the special bond that some of us are privileged to share with an animal. I have had and still have many wonderful horses—but there was one so remarkable and our relationship so special, that as you say, it almost sounded “a bit too mystical or cliché” when I try to capture it in words. I couldn’t help but to think of Pepper the whole way through War Horse, tears streaming down my face the whole time.

And guess what? The first off-Broadway production of the play actually will be here in Boise, Idaho! I’ll be there, too, with my box of Kleenex.



Alayne 08 Jan 2012 1:59 PM

Stephanie, your comments are spot on for the movie!  My daughter and I saw the movie together...we are both horse lovers, have loved the same horse who has preceded us over the Rainbow Bridge, and loved every moment of the movie, even through our tears.  Steph also saw the play in London last summer while traveling with one of her equine classes from the University of Louisville.  When I asked which she liked more (after both of us having read the book), she said each is a unique telling of the story.  I only hope the play comes to the Dallas/Fort Worth area!  



Anna 08 Jan 2012 2:46 PM

I too cried all through the movie and all the way home. My poor boyfriend just didn’t know what to do with me . It was such a wonderful family movie. I applaud Steven as well for the lack of gore that usually comes with any war movie. You don’t need all of that mess to tell the tale, and he made it to where the whole family could go and see it. GREAT JOB STEVEN WELL DONE!  I can’t wait to have it on DVD so I can show my great grandma; she was a farm girl and shares my profound love for horses. Very well written article, I started tearing up remembering scenes in the movie.  



lyndsey 08 Jan 2012 3:22 PM

War Horse depicts friendship and perseverance. I saw the play in NYC and loved the movements of the puppets. I saw the movie right after its debut Christmas Day. Like the other comments, was teary-eyed throughout most of the movie. So happy to hear the barbed wire scene was a harmless material. I have a trakhner gelding that I have a wonderful relationship with. I can't imagine someone trying to take him away from me. Albert's love and perseverance is evident. Loved the scene with Emilie trying to get Joey to jump. Funny :)



Carolyn 08 Jan 2012 3:42 PM

Thanks, Carol, Diane, Alayne, Anna, Lyndsey, and Carolyn. I enjoyed reading your comments. May we all have a bond with a horse as Joey's with Albert. Alayne, that's awesome that the play will be coming to Boise when it goes off broadway! My hope is to get to NYC to see it at some point soon.



Stephanie 09 Jan 2012 8:26 AM

I was fortunate enough to be invited to the premeire at the Lincoln Theatre in DC whereI met Valerie Ormond and her husband, Hyman. Valerie has written a book "Believing In Horses" which I haven't read yet but she is currently working on a book about the Wounded Warriors' Therapeutic Ride program--one of the beneficiaries of the premeire's fund-raising efforts. (Funds also went to the Maryland A Home For Every Horse program) Both worthy causes. About the movie, the only disappointment I experienced was when Joey is "put to the plow" and all the neighbors show up.  I anticipated an outpouring of support--a team of drafts,perhaps?-from the surrounding villagers ala Its a Wonderful Life when everyone George helped showed up to bail him out. But I suppose that was the point:  the man needed to stop drinking and deal with reality.  I was real happy to see Emily Watson, she's always a treat!  A great book by Jilly Cooper "Animals In War" for those interested in true war-horse stories:>



Beverly 10 Jan 2012 1:36 PM

Great artile! I saw War Horse yesterday, and I cried more during the previews than the movie, although I did go through 7 tissues! This was truly a love story between the humans and Joey. Did anyone else cry when Albert and Joey were first plowing the field and Joey finally plowed the field for Albert? Or when Joey showed Tophorn how to wear a halter? It was truly a moving story and I can't wait until it comes out on DVD.



Sandra 12 Jan 2012 8:39 AM

My son,his girlfriend, my mother and I tried to see this movie, we keep getting interpreted by theater, first a fire alarm went off, then they thought that they were showing the wrong movie, after it was all said and done with we must have missed 45 min of the move and latter on found out that we missed 2 different seines that played huge parts in the movie,but over all what I did see was a great picture and can not wait to get it on DVD so I can see it in its entirety.



Dawn 27 Jan 2012 10:17 PM

I read the book before I saw the movie and while I loved both versions, I was surprised at greatly the two differed. Read the book to see what I mean. I found the barbed wire scence the most difficult to watch. A real horse would have months of rehab if he survived at all. Other horse friends of mine talked about how the didn't like the movie because horses wouldn't really do some of the things portrayed. I think they missed the point that the story was about "the bond".



Karla 24 Feb 2012 2:57 PM

I read the book before I saw the movie to prepare myself for the sad parts so I wouldn't cry at the theater - it didn't work! One thing struck me as a truly loving scene, when Albert thought he had to give Joey up to the French grandfather, he did his best to be cheerful for Joey's sake. THAT scene made me cry all over again!



Virginia 07 Mar 2012 9:15 PM