I don't think the debate in this country will ever end over the slaughter of horses for human consumption; it's just too emotional an issue. The closing of the last equine slaughter plants was done through local and state lawmakers and, ultimately, by the federal government stopping the funding of meat inspectors at U.S. equine slaughter facilities. Contrary to what some people believe, the federal government has not passed any legislation that says the slaughter of horses for meat in the United States is illegal. Now the downturn in the economy and the issue of states' rights versus federal rights have brought horse slaughter facilities back to the forefront of industry discussions (see Update on State Slaughter Resolutions; Idaho Joins Debate), and we remain a country divided.
People in some states have a more agrarian outlook on horses; they see horses as livestock. This doesn't mean horses aren't appreciated or loved. The horse as livestock rather than “companion animal” is a reality to many in the United States.
The current battle lines, however, are being drawn not over the moral issues of horse slaughter, but over states' rights versus federal rights to have international commerce, i.e., equine slaughter facilities that export horsemeat.
Could Canadian meat inspectors come across the border to inspect horsemeat, or could the meat be shipped to Canada for inspection? That remains to be seen.
My prediction is that by the end of 2009 there will be an active equine slaughter facility in the United States, or at least the building of one will be under way in a state that has fought for that right.
So, if we have equine slaughter again in this country, can we make the process of getting there more humane? We need better laws concerning handling of horses at sales and during transportation.
Welfare Worsens
There are more and more stories of horses being abandoned, shot (and sometimes not even killed), starved, left to die, turned out on federal lands ... the list goes on. Some tell of going on trail rides for a day only to come back and find their trailer full of unwanted horses. Horse sales report owners leaving animals if they don't sell. Sale and show facility managers find horses in barns where there aren't even sales or shows under way! Farm owners report horses showing up in their fields overnight.
Then there are tens of thousands of BLM horses languishing in holding facilities unable to be adopted, euthanized, or sent to slaughter. This program costs millions of dollars each year, and keeping some feral horses in pens for years seems more inhumane to me than euthanasia.
The economy is going to get worse before it gets better, and some horse owners are going to have to give up their horses. What's to become of those animals?
The news says 47 of 50 states have budget deficits, and the federal government is more concerned about people losing jobs and homes than horses losing owners. If you can take another horse, please do. If not, help however you can.